Skip to main content

Questioning Strategies


It's been ten years since I've graduated high school, so my memory is probably less than accurate, but: I can't recall specific moments where my teachers used effective questioning strategies. This could mean a few things: a) They were exceptionally skilled at starting dialogue in the classroom to the point of going unnoticed by us teenagers, b) they didn't pose meaningful questions to get us started on asking our own meaningful questions, leading to dialogue, or c) my memory is really just that terrible. 

Most of the time, I think my teachers simply asked questions, and students either responded or didn't. But maybe it's because I was (am) quiet and doodling in my notebook the majority of the time (still do... sigh) and wasn't paying attention that I can't remember any mind blowing conversations that left me leaving class feeling sucker-punched (in all the best ways possible, of course). At least, not conversations that were teacher led. Actually, I think the most important and enlightening conversations I had around course material and connecting it to real life happened with my peers during group work or in the way back of the classroom.

Anyway. The questioning strategy I've decided to share with you all is all about generating student voice and keeping the dialogue going back and forth between students versus student-teacher. It's called "FY3." 

During class discussions, you ask students to FY3 their responses. FY3 is "shorthand for diversify, verify, and amplify." Basically, you want students to think of responses to their peers that a) provide multiple perspectives, b) back up their claims, and c) elaborate on an idea or ideas. As the teacher who shared this strategy says, this is more of a scaffolding strategy that helps students work on their discussion skills, but I think it could also be used to generate questions as well. By using a strategy like FY3, there are structures in place that help students begin to pinpoint how they want to respond to questions. From personal experience, sometimes being asked a question, especially an open-ended one, can be a little difficult because the mind is racing with a million thoughts at once. Instead of answering my brain tends to lean on the "shut down" end of the spectrum (working on it). But by practicing how I should begin to respond, there's less pressure. I think this could be true for students, too.

That said -- I realize this is more of an answer strategy than a questioning one... but I think it'd be helpful in getting conversation going nonetheless. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Critical Literacy and Resistant Perspective Reading

In his article "What is Critical Literacy?" Ira Shor reflects that critical literacy is "words rethinking worlds, self dissenting in society," bridging "the political and the personal, the public and the private, the global and the local, the economic and the pedagogical" (282) so that a truly just society may come to pass, where none are oppressed or silenced. Shor encourages educators in particular to teach critically -- not just for their students' well-being, but out of mutuality, a shared effort to break away from the injustices of society and work toward bettering it as a whole (291). This means, then, that the lessons and materials we share with our students have implications, for better or worse. "Every educator [...] orients students towards certain values, actions, and language with implications for the kind of society and people these behaviors will produce (Shor 300). As a future ELA teacher, these words, of course, have me thinki...
1 comment
Read more

A New Year and Manifesto

Hello everyone, Jessica here. I'm using the blog I used back for 445 so if you see previous entries (full of typos and half-formed thoughts, eek) that's why. It's nice to keep this blog going though and be able to reflect on what I wrote before. For my manifesto, I decided to write a poem... not sure if that's allowed but being that a manifesto is a declaration of sorts, the poetic form worked (hopefully), at least for me and sorting through my thoughts which are often scatter-brained one-liners. "Manifesto" I am a teacher who does not seek straight-backed rows of tucked in selves and compliance, but freedom clanging like bells mirrored in my students' eyes and laughter, only their chimes are louder. Fire sharpened and kindled on the lives of one another, creating a new, better world, where love is possible, not dampened by the weight of fill-in-the-blank dots  and their own ellipses of quiet and pain. I am a teac...
5 comments
Read more

Failure is not a permanent condition?

When Thomas briefly compares Growth Mindset's popularity to that of policies which stress "grit" and "no excuses," it instantly made me think of Angela Duckworth, a psychologist who recently published a book titled Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance . I actually purchased this book because I found it interesting how at the beginning she detailed her life growing up in her father's shadow; he was a man who sought brilliance and expected nothing less from her. This led her on a journey to figure out, scientifically, what "grit" is -- what enables certain individuals to go above and beyond for their goals, while others seemingly display no drive?  I never ended up finishing the book, but after reading Thomas' post I'm pulled back to the question of grit. How do you "curate" a characteristic in an individual? As he points out, an issue with these philosophies and approaches to poverty-stricken students is this: they plac...
4 comments
Read more